Hardy Plumbing
January 12, 2011

Diss Functional Opinions

(click for larger version)
In this corner . . . Malone vs. Fleming, then Nuzzi vs. Throne-Holst, then Fleming vs. Nuzzi, then Throne-Holst vs. Malone, not to mention a free-for-all double bill Throne -Holst vs. Malone and Nuzzi vs. Fleming simultaneously.

Last Friday, what was supposed to be a simple work session reviewing the agenda for yesterday's Southampton Town Board meeting descended into a series of verbal skirmishes, with bubbling resentment among majority and minority members boiling over and enmity escalating to a new level.

While there was a new level of ire, debate over departmental organization has been going on for weeks.

Warm fuzzies have been in short supply in town hall since last fall, when members of the Republican majority Chris Nuzzi, Jim Malone and Nancy Graboski tanked Supervisor Anna Throne- Holst's plan to reorganize certain departments and put forth their own philosophy regarding how the General Services and Comptroller's offices should function.

Along with Democratic minority member Councilwoman Bridget Fleming, Throne-Holst, who proposed abolishing the position of Commissioner of General Services and passing some of that department's duties over to Comptroller Tamara Wright, complained of an eleventh hour budgetary ambush. The Republican threesome adopted a budget that kept the office, then voted to install Russell Kratoville as head, a move that elicited scorching criticism from Democrats and community members supportive of the supervisor. The GOP-supported budget cut spending by one percent while the supervisor's proposal raised them by a little over two percent.

Resolutions relating to the ongoing disagreement about how the two departments should operate kicked off Friday's snipefest, which morphed into high volume accusation, then ratcheted up to a verbal brawl, with the supervisor attempting to end the discussion and Malone rebuking her for chastising council members. Telling the supervisor, "You can stop the scolding," Malone admonished, "You know what? This is not your breakfast table and I'm not one of your children."

Last month, Fleming put forth a measure restoring staff to the comptroller's office. It was summarily squashed by the GOP majority, members of which said they wanted to maintain staffing levels outlined in the adopted budget. On Friday Fleming re-introduced her bill and Nuzzi proposed a resolution directing the comptroller's office to provide financial information, spurring the latest display of internecine ire.

Both moves, along with a third resolution revising the duties of the General Services department, were slated for vote at the town board meeting held as Indy went to press yesterday, but Throne-Holst urged colleagues to hold off until after a comprehensive work session on the matters scheduled for this coming Friday.

Although she said she supported the supervisor's request to discuss the allocation of tasks and staff during a work session, Fleming admitted she put the resolution on the agenda because "it's the only way I can get my foot in the door." She said she discussed the matter with Malone and it "went nowhere."

Malone was offended by the assertions and said as much.

Nuzzi said he was offended by Wright's notation in the fiscal impact section of his bill directing the comptroller's office to provide "basic financial information." (See sidebar for additional information about financial reporting effort.) The fiscal impact section called for a new $75,000 position in Wright's office. Nuzzi and Malone both derided the "ridiculous" notation, suggesting it was a back door move to increase the comptroller's staff. A financial impact statement isn't designed to be a lobbying effort for more help, Malone said adding that if Wright didn't know that, "I'm wondering whether we've got the right comptroller." Throne-Holst argued Wright has served the town "exceedingly well."

Complaining that the only way to get the information he wanted "and is entitled to," was through a directive in a resolution, Nuzzi said to the supervisor the information he seeks is data which Wright "claims to have, which you claim she has every day, which she better have because she's the one watching out on a daily basis of what our finances are."

Throne-Holst insisted the information is "plopped in to the town clerk's office" each month and is readily available. However, if the councilman needs it in a different format, it would require more staff, she said. The supervisor said Wright was "deeply offended" that Nuzzi failed to speak with her first before sponsoring the move. When the councilman claimed to have had numerous conversations with the comptroller, the supervisor interjected "no you have not."

As happened several times that morning, the discussion then descended into a 'did so/did not' type interchange more often seen on schoolyards. Each member of the board (except Graboski, who was absent) at one point accused a colleague of making statements that were untrue. The heated outing climaxed with arguments raging at both ends of the dais. While Malone demanded "respect for the office" from Throne-Holst, Fleming clashed with Nuzzi referencing the controversy surrounding the appointment of "crony" Kratoville and efforts to aggrandize his office. "Just stop. Stop. Stop with the rhetoric," Nuzzi interrupted, chastising the councilwoman for resorting to a "mantra" dissing the Republican majority. "Be responsible in your position here as a town board member," he said.

Fleming reminded that her responsibility as a minority member to watch the majority and "put the brakes on" when necessary, particularly when moves invite controversy and anger.

If there is anger and frustration, Malone interjected, it's because the Democrat minority refuses to acknowledge and accept decisions made during the budget process. Stating he had no interest in another discussion of staffing, Nuzzi directed his comments to the supervisor. "It seems we can have a hundred work sessions, but apparently in your world, we will continue to talk up until the point everybody agrees with you."

When the supervisor said, again, that she'd schedule a work session on the issues, Malone said "let's do it respectfully and have respect for the offices we hold."

"I think those were my very words," Throne–Holst replied.

"Well, then live by them," Malone countered.

  1. print email
    Disgraceful behavior
    January 13, 2011 | 02:36 PM

    Referring to the work session of January 7th Fleming and ATH just can’t stop with the political theatre and drama. I don’t agree with the way the Director of General Services was hired but enough is enough. Nuzzi was asking for a financial report that was simple to follow. After all he is an elected official too and he should be able to get what he wants. ATH can’t seem to let go and needs to micro manage everything.

    ATH and Fleming keep saying that the Comptroller Tamara Wright has too much work? Then why is ATH and Bridget looking to add more responsibility to the already overworked Ms. Wright? Does Ms. Wright have the time to take on some of the responsibility of General Services? Or is this just a power grab for Ms. Throne-Holst? She gets rid of General Services so that she can oversee all of Personnel and hire who she wants. Was getting rid of General Services about saving the town money? Or was it about a power grab?

    We all know that Tamara Wright is a friend of Anna’s and donated $1800 to her election campaign a couple of years ago. Tamara is Anna’s girl; she will do anything Anna wants. Tamara first worked for the town p/t helping out the previous comptroller. She was handed the job as Comptroller without any other person being interviewed nor was the job opened up to the general public.

    This behavior at the work session was disgraceful and a waste of tax payer money. In my view both Bridget and ATH are using town board meeting’s and work sessions as a platform for running for the next election.

    Disgusted taxpayer
  2. print email
    Political Theatre
    January 13, 2011 | 09:14 PM

    Hurray for disgusted taxpayer. I want to join your club. In recent days, I have had the exact same thoughts. ATH & Fleming have to stop using meeting for political gain. Fleming thinks she is a defense lawyer at town board meeting when cross examining the "majority". She forget where she was and called the Supervisor "Your Honor"! Lets send her back to court come November!
    AND WHO THE HELL IS GEORGE LYNCH! Heard he's writing a book - he must be the star of his own imagination!

    also disgusted taxpayer
Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback.
* required value
Your Name*




Site Search

2107 Capeletti Front Tile
Gurney's Inn